Cliodynamics is one of those ideas you might half-joke about in the pub: predicting the future by paying close attention to the past.
But it’s no joke.
Cliodynamics treats history as a science. It uses mathematical models and large datasets—economic, demographic, political—to identify long-term patterns in social systems. In his recent book End Times (2023), cliodynamics founder Peter Turchin argues that large institutions repeatedly move through cycles of growth, strain, fragmentation, and reform. Different eras. Same patterns
As a behavioural scientist, and as someone who has worked with, and within, the NHS for nearly forty years, I think cliodynamics offers something quietly powerful: perspective rather than prophecy.
- It helps us notice the patterns beneath the policy churn.
- It reminds us that ideas rarely die—they recycle.
- New language. Fresh branding. Old bones.
Take locality planning.
Working for Patients (1989), the White Paper underpinning the NHS and Community Care Act 1990, introduced locality-based planning through health authority purchasing and GP fundholding. Care shaped around local populations. Needs assessed locally. Money following local decisions. Planning guidance laboured the point, and special funding flowed to make it happen.
Fast forward thirty years.
Integrated Neighbourhood Teams arrived via the NHS Long Term Plan (2019), sharpened by the Fuller Stocktake (2022), and formalised in NHS England guidance (2023). Same idea. Older soul. Organise care around place, not institutions. Power closer to home. Would reference the NHS 10 Year Plan (2025)
Or take system leadership.
Strategic Health Authorities were introduced through Shifting the Balance of Power within the NHS (2001). Regional Health Authorities were dismantled. Decision-making was said to move closer to the frontline. Power was “devolved”—though accountability was largely rearranged, not reduced.
Fast forward twenty years.
Integrated Care Boards emerged through the Health and Care Act (2022), animated by the ICS Design Framework (2021). Legislation set the bones. Guidance gave them breath. New custodians of planning, money, and accountability—at system level.
Fast forward another 30 years
And then there’s the purchaser–provider split.
In Working for Patients (1990), the NHS drew a hard line: commissioners would buy care, providers would sell it. Contracts replaced handshakes. Money followed decisions. A faint whiff of market air in a public service.
The backlash came. The language softened. Collaboration became the watchword. The split was never fully dismantled—just spoken about more gently.
Today, under Integrated Care Systems, we act as if it has vanished. It hasn’t. Someone still allocates resources. Someone still delivers. Money still moves, for reasons.
The NHS didn’t abandon the purchaser–provider split.
It learned to dress it differently.
So—are we wiser?
That depends on your perspective. Eminent commentators will argue either way. But cliodynamics would suggest this is exactly what large, complex systems do. As Turchin (2023) observes, institutional reform rarely moves in straight lines; it oscillates, revisiting familiar solutions under new pressures.
For me, the lesson is simple: change in the NHS is cyclical. The patterns return. Only the labels shift.
Cliodynamics doesn’t stop the wheel turning. But it helps us breathe as it does.
When we see the cycles, we stop mistaking repetition for failure—and start making sense of change as something patterned, human, and entirely predictable.
The questions this raises are:
- How can Cliodynamics inform our future planning to make it more effective and efficient?
- How can we keep the human element, be resilient in this changing world an create an overstanding of our self and others to see the broader picture
Author Jude Goddard
After a degree in Behavioural Sciences and an MA in Health Policy, Jude began her career as a Probation Officer before becoming a Director of Strategy in the NHS. She later established her own consultancy, trained as a psychotherapist and professional mediator, and continues to work as a strategic adviser and organisational development consultant to the English NHS



0 Comments